Step 4: Photograph and list everything, room by room
A clear list is the foundation of a fair process. Everyone, including relatives who live far away, can see exactly what there is.
- Work one room at a time. Start with the least emotional room, such as a spare room or the garage, to build a rhythm.
- Take one photo of the whole item, and a close-up of any mark, label or damage.
- Give each item a short title and note where it was found.
- Put anything that might be valuable (jewellery, art, antiques, instruments, collections) in a separate group to be valued later.
- A spreadsheet or a shared photo album will do. An app like Keep it, Sell it, Donate it handles the photographing, the list and the voting in one place.
Step 5: Let everyone say what they want before anything leaves
Many family arguments start when one person takes something early. A simple rule helps: nothing leaves the house until everyone has seen the list and had a chance to speak. Families commonly use one of these approaches.
- Everyone marks what they want first. Compare the marks. Most items turn out to be wanted by one person, or by nobody.
- Take turns choosing. Draw lots for who goes first, then alternate picks.
- Discuss the clashes separately. Items that more than one person wants are talked through after everything else is settled.
- Share copies. Photographs, scans and recordings let several people keep a memory of the same thing.
- Include everyone. Relatives overseas or in another city can take part through photos.
For a fuller comparison of methods, see our guide to dividing a parent's belongings between siblings.
Step 6: Settle disagreements fairly
Sooner or later two people will want the same item. Try these in order.
- Ask each person why it matters to them. Often one person cares about the memory and the other about the object.
- Look for a swap. One person takes it and the other chooses something of similar meaning or value.
- Take turns. The item goes to one person for a set time, then to the other, if that is practical.
- Make a copy or take a photograph so both people keep something.
- If both agree, sell it and split the money.
- Ask a neutral person to make the final call, such as the executor, a trusted relative or a mediator. In the app this person is called the Decider.
A simple majority is rarely a good way to settle a sentimental item, because the person who wants it most can be outvoted. Agree in advance who has the final say.